NY Judge Says “Whoa” to Mandatory Vaccinations of First Responders

In my blog posted October 8 here on FireDaily.com, I addressed some of the concerns of my buddy, Brett, a local firefighter/paramedic, regarding flu vaccinations for first responders. One of his questions: Could his employer, in the name of public safety, force him to get vaccinated against his will as a term of his employment?

Well, let the games begin.

Earlier today, Acting New York State Supreme Court Justice Thomas J. McNamara granted a temporary restraining order against mandated flu vaccinations for certain health care workers.

The New York Health Commission had previously ordered that certain employees must be vaccinated for both the seasonal and the H1N1 flu by November 30 or face the possibility of disciplinary action, including dismissal.

Three nurses from the Albany Medical Center claimed the regulation violates their civil rights. The New York State United Teachers Union and the New York State Public Employees Federation also sued. McNamara merged all three lawsuits under the restraining order and set a court date for October 30.

Of course, this was bound to happen. And I fully expect similar cases to arise at the state and local levels all across the country in the upcoming days and weeks.

So, do you think the government has the right to dictate your health care decisions during a pandemic?

-J

FireDaily.com will continue following all the developments on the pandemic, specifically its effects on first responders.

2 Comments

  • Ckemtp says:

    Today was the day that I had to choose whetere or not to get vaccinated for the dreaded H1N1. My medical director came personally to the service and convinced me to take the vaccine.

    I wasn't planning on getting it. I asked him about what I've heard against the vaccine. He allayed my fears, personally vouched for the vaccination, and convinced me to get it.

    So far, my arm hurst. Ow… other than that, I've yet to sprout a snout or hooves.

  • Ckemtp says:

    Today was the day that I had to choose whetere or not to get vaccinated for the dreaded H1N1. My medical director came personally to the service and convinced me to take the vaccine.

    I wasn't planning on getting it. I asked him about what I've heard against the vaccine. He allayed my fears, personally vouched for the vaccination, and convinced me to get it.

    So far, my arm hurst. Ow… other than that, I've yet to sprout a snout or hooves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

background image Blogger Img

John Mitchell

Firefighter/Paramedic and a Lieutenant in suburban Chicago
Comments
Rob
Packing heat with our halligan and a Glock by our gloves?
I was a volunteer for almost twenty years. When our members were police officers, they could carry on duty, concealed. I remember one night when I was the operator (driver) and responding to a house fire, three of the four firefighters on the truck were PD. I was handed three sidearms to take care of!…
2014-01-27 22:54:00
bhill
Packing heat with our halligan and a Glock by our gloves?
"lockbox on the truck" Does he carry his weapon in a lock box while on duty as a Deputy? I'm thinkin' not. Am I willing to use deadly force, and then turn around and try to save their life after I shoot them? Ain't happening. "individuals with police/weapons training" - the training teaches shoot to…
2014-01-27 19:33:00
Ken Nelson
Packing heat with our halligan and a Glock by our gloves?
I believe individuals with police/weapons training should carry fire arms. In our station's situation, our assistant chief is also a sheriff's deputy. I have suggested that he have his firearm with him in a lockbox on the truck in case a need arises. In addition some personnel are current military (Reserve, National Guard) who could…
2014-01-27 18:20:00
Marianna Randazzo
We Should Be Hearing All About Mike Behette Today, Rather Than Knowing So Much About the Navy Yard Shooter.
Thank you for this wonderful tribute to my dear friend Mike. I am in the process of writing a biography/anthology of Michael's life. I would be very grateful for your input. Please contact me on FB, Marianna Randazzo or Given Away, A SIiclian Upbringing. Respectfully yours, Marianna
2013-12-07 02:51:00
Fire Daily
WARNING: This video is graphic and depicts a man being rescued from his burning home.
Yes, Becky, I saw that too. As I was told by an ER doc many moons ago, "a patient without an airway is a dead patient." Not all firefighters are EMT's, and some may not have basic first aid skills- instead relying on a concurrent response from an emergency EMS agency. Not sure in this…
2013-11-27 11:27:00
Give It The Best That You Have
First Day Back
First Day Back
New Leaders: JFK's Nightmare
New Leaders: JFK's Nightmare
It's OK.
It's OK.
Welcome to the Club
Welcome to the Club

John Mitchell's Discussions


Follow John Mitchell
Toledo prayers

YOU CAME FROM

FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

LATEST FIREFIGHTER NEWS

HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS

LATEST ON FIRE ENGINEERING

FEATURED DISCUSSIONS